Monster City Book Review

Last week, I discussed the Colorado case of the Watts family murders. In this week’s blog post, I review Monster City: Murder, Music, and Mayhem in Nashville’s Dark Age.

The Central Character

Monster City is a book by criminologist and author Michael Arntfield, Ph.D. It is part biography (of detective Pat Postiglione), part crime history, and part criminal psychology. With so many threads, the book has something for just about everyone.

Detective Sergeant Patrick Postiglione grew up in New York City, where he worked in his father’s heating and air conditioning business. A stint in the military left him with two goals: to see the South and find a law enforcement career. As part of his first ambition, he took a “vacation” to Nashville, Tennessee, in January 1978, which became permanent. In 1980, he was part of the Nashville Police Academy’s last training session of 1980.

The protagonist of Monster City, Pat Postiglione with his wife, Margaret.
Patrolman Pat Postiglione (R) with his wife, Margaret

From patrolman, Postiglione quickly worked his way up to homicide detective. As a detective, he showed unusual ability and seemed particularly adept at closing serial homicides and cold cases. Arntfield follows Postiglione’s career by examining several cases he worked on and solved. Many of these were years or decades old.

The Cases Featured in Monster City

Arntfield organizes Monster City around six significant investigations. First is the Vandyland Murders, a series of murders occurring near the campus of Vanderbilt University. Second are the Motel Murders, the murders of high-risk women in seedy motels in Nashville and elsewhere. Third is the Dive Bar murders, the random killing of an aspiring musician and his wife who had just arrived in Nashville trying to make it big in Music City, USA. Fourth is the Tanning Bed murders at a “tanning studio” on Church Street. Fifth, the Fast Food murders. Sixth and perhaps the most challenging is the Rest Stop murders since the killer was a long-haul trucker who could be anywhere.

Although the six investigations form the nexus of the book’s organization, Arntfield also mentions cases. It is a thorough picture of Nashville crime from the mid-1970s through the first decade of the twenty-first century.

My Take on Monster City

Monster City held my complete attention from the first page to the last. Not only are the stories fascinating to true crime fans, but Arntfield tells them with a panache that keeps his readers enthralled. I enthusiastically recommend it.


I have something of a personal connection to the book. I grew up in the Nashville area, and although most of the crimes described in the book occurred after I moved on, two did not. The murder of Sarah Des Prez occurred a block from the campus during the time I was a student at Vanderbilt, but I do not recall it. The disappearance of Marcia Trimble was another story. When the nine-year-old went missing from her Green Hills home, it was a massive local news story. Newscasts on all three local television stations prominently and repeatedly displayed her picture until her body was found.

Pat Postiglione, Deadly Recall, Nashville, Tennessee, 2019

I left Nashville three years before Pat Postiglione hit the streets as a rookie cop. Therefore, I was long gone before he started making a name for himself as a homicide detective.

Don’t Miss Out! Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe to True Crime in the News, a monthly email newsletter that looks at recent news stories that will interest any true crime fan. There is also a summary of the previous month’s blog posts. You won’t want to miss this. Join the newsletter mailing list today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *